So far best Album I listened to this year by Gnarls Barkley - St. ElsewhereUmbrella Shoulder HolderTickets: First Virgin America FlightCAT: Fling a String

John Chow got Banned from Google

Filed in Uncategorized 12 comments

Will Random Good Stuff be next?

Shortly after I published the "Linkbait Friday" campaign yesterday RGS reader Mike left this this comment:

I dont wanna spoil the fun, but this kinda linkbait got john chow banned from google

Thanks to that I could not sleep … all night I was thinking "Will RGS be banned from Google because of Linkbait Friday?"

So I decided to take a closer look in the case of John Chow:

john chow

Read his very first blog post in December 2005 here.

And Shortly after his traffic went:

john-chow--traffic

In December 2006 he decided to run a LinkBaiting Campaign and he offered every blog reviewing his site in context of making money blogging a link to the reviewers site. Random Good Stuff could not resist :)

Well he got banned from Google for that … Chris Hemphill got the whole scoop.

Did John Chow suffer because of that? Not at all .. as you can see in the graph above.

See for yourself and google search John Chow … no link to his site.

Now, high up in the results is John Cow and as you can see that sites shows up on the first google page. That witty webmaster took advantage of John Chow’s ban and is guiding lost sheep in the search of John Chow to his site. With great success as you can see:

john-cow-traffic

WOW!

Bastard .. lol ;)

Now back to RGS … John Chow might be able to survive a ban from Google ….. Random Good Stuff probably won’t so now the question will my Linkbait Friday get me into trouble with Google? Please Vote:

In my case I am not asking for a review about RGS with a specific anchor text. I am offering my content and ask for a via: link and every Friday I want to link to everyone taking part in a thank you post with a link to their site. Is that really that bad?

Looking especially forward to get Feedback from following Dot Com Moguls:

If you have any input you can back up feel free to post them as a comment. And until further notice I will put my Linkbait Friday on hold, don’t feel like getting banned … yet ;)

Small Banner

Posted by   @   15 September 2007 12 comments
Comments
Sep 15, 2007
1:01 pm
#1 Daniel :

Creating a post every Friday with a link to readers that “talked” about your blog should not get you into trouble.

Be careful how you structure the whole deal, though. John Chow did not suffer much from getting banned in Google because he has a very popular blog and an incredibly active community. I bet that he could choose, though, he would rather have his Google SE traffic back (which should be around 1,000 hits per day or say by the time he was banner).

Google lays down the rules, and if you can’t beat them, you better join them :).

Sep 15, 2007
5:50 pm
#2 Maki :

To answer your question: No, I don’t you will get banned for this exercise. Hope this helps. :)

Sep 16, 2007
4:23 am
#3 tuvie :

I believe you’re gonna be okay.

Sep 17, 2007
11:54 am
#4 Al :

I think it depends how you word it, if you say you want links and will link back in return in order to manipulate rankings then you’re going against Google’s terms and if you get penalised you’d only have your self to blame, though I highly doubt Google would notice.

Sep 17, 2007
1:28 pm
#5 tuvie :

hey al, you mean if the link exchange’s done without any money, it would be okay ? so basically google found out about the money because of the post, if John didn’t mention any money, then he will be just find ?

Sep 17, 2007
1:32 pm
#6 RGS :

Tuvie,

as far as I know John never offered any money. Or am I wrong?

Sep 17, 2007
1:41 pm
#7 tuvie :

ops, sorry, I misread, so he was just offering a link back right ? I don’t see what’s wrong with that … btw, I just google “john chow” (without the quote) and I see 2,5 million results. Are you sure google banned John Chow ?

Sep 17, 2007
1:45 pm
#8 RGS :

Yeah he is banned … because you will not find a google result linking directly to his own site http://www.johnchow.com . He should be number one.

Sep 21, 2007
7:06 pm
#9 elysa :

I linked to you in a recent post that was fitting of my topic so whether or not you link back wasn’t my reason for linking to you. I think the thankyou post will be ok though. But I am certainly not an expert.

Trackbacks to this post.
Leave a Comment

Previous Post
«
Next Post
»
Random Good Stuff © 2005-2010 - All Rights Reserved | Contact